Why I Avoid Stock Photography on My Personal Site
Stock photography is efficient for filling a page. A generic photograph of a smiling team, an open-plan office or a city skyline can make a design feel finished before the words have been read. The trouble is that polish is often rented from a visual library, where the same images circulate across countless brands, publications and campaign pages. When I choose one, the site starts talking in someone else’s vocabulary. I keep stock libraries out of this project because I want the images to belong to the same voice as the writing.
A personal site can be useful without presenting every polished surface. It can show how I notice a street, choose a typeface, edit a photograph or arrange a page. Those decisions carry evidence of authorship. A stock image substitutes a prebuilt answer for that evidence. It may be competent and visually pleasing, yet difficult to connect with the person publishing it. Avoiding stock imagery gives the site more coherence and lets the photographs retain some friction, imperfection and geographical specificity.
Stock Images Create a Borrowed Voice
The quickest way to make a personal site look anonymous is to decorate it with imagery designed for nobody in particular. A staged handshake, a laptop on a pale desk or a woman laughing in an abstract park communicates broad professional ideas, but not a life in Australia. It could belong to a bank, a software launch or a fictional family. The visitor notices the category, not the person.
Stock libraries also flatten differences between subjects. Their search tools reward common keywords, repeatable compositions and interchangeable corporate moods. Two sites can buy similarly lit people, similarly tidy desks and similarly muted colour palettes, creating a visual sameness that makes personal work look like a campaign for the same imaginary company. If my site is meant to reveal how I see, that sameness works against the idea.
None of this makes stock photography bad. A well-chosen picture can inform, explain or carry emotion, especially in editorial work. The mismatch occurs when a generic file is asked to perform the intimate role of a personal signature. On my own site, the burden of proof is different: the image should contribute context that the writing cannot supply alone. That higher requirement is easier to meet with work I have observed, commissioned or deliberately made.
Authenticity Comes From Specific Details
Original photography can begin with place. A frame of Melbourne’s laneways and tram tracks carries a different atmosphere from a generic urban image, just as Sydney’s harbour-edge apartments reveal another set of surfaces, shadows and routines. These scenes do not need to announce a city with a landmark. They can show where a particular morning happened, which makes the picture harder to confuse with a photograph taken somewhere else.
The camera can also record everyday Australian habits without turning them into stereotypes. A refillable bottle beside a flat white, a council recycling bin on a footpath or sunlight crossing a front verandah says something specific about daily life. Such details are small, but they give the site texture and time. The image remains connected to a place and a routine rather than functioning as a neutral backdrop for copy.
This approach does not require expensive equipment. A phone, a scan of a printed photograph or a carefully cropped detail can carry more personality than a technically perfect but contextless asset. The personal archive grows through observation: repeated windows, handwritten notes, work tables and changing streets. People in those frames should know how they will be used, and their presence should serve the story rather than simply add a human face to fill empty space.
Licensing Matters in Australia
A stock licence is easy to misunderstand. Paying for a download or seeing the words “royalty-free” does not grant every possible use. Australia’s Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) protects photographs, and a licence may limit duration, territory, print quantity, social media use, resale or use in merchandise. Some images are sold for editorial use only, which can exclude advertising a product or service. The receipt is not the permission; the licence terms are.
A separate issue is what appears in the frame. Identifiable people may need a model release, while private premises, distinctive interiors, logos and artworks can raise separate consent, property or trademark questions. Clear commissioning terms should state ownership, permitted uses, duration and territory. This matters when work is made in Melbourne’s independent design scene or Sydney’s small-business market, where a photograph might move quickly from a website into packaging, social posts or a local campaign.
AI-generated pictures are not stock photographs, yet they can reproduce the same shortcut. Their training data, subjects and commercial terms may be unclear, and an apparently realistic scene can invent social or cultural details. Australia’s Privacy Act 1988 may apply depending on the publisher’s structure and the data involved, while state and territory privacy rules can also be relevant. More broadly, a synthetic image should not be presented as documentary evidence when it is not.
Art Direction Outranks Convenience
Convenience is the strongest argument for stock libraries, but it is a poor guide to art direction. A personal page needs an image that fits its exact proportions, surrounding words, colour balance and emotional temperature. A generic asset must often be cropped into several shapes and tinted to match a layout. Original or commissioned photography can be made for the job, so the frame supports the composition instead of forcing the page around it.
Responsive design makes that control especially valuable. The same picture may need to become a wide banner, a narrow column and a small mobile crop, and each version can lose a different part of the subject. Stock files are often designed around a conventional central crop, while a photograph with room to move can offer a clear focal point in one format and a secondary detail in another. Better direction reduces visual noise on every screen size.
Restraint also changes how images are used. One considered photograph, surrounded by white space and carefully set type, can say more than a grid of interchangeable pictures. The site gains a pace because each image has been selected rather than recruited to fill space. This approach suits the kind of restrained web design I want to explore: typography first, image as a precise contribution, and no decorative layer added merely because an empty corner seemed available.
Speed, Accessibility and Restraint
Large stock files can also slow the experience. A high-resolution campaign photograph may weigh several megabytes, and when it becomes the largest element on a page it can delay the Largest Contentful Paint. Visitors on mobile data or a patchy connection notice the wait before they understand what the site is about. Original images can be the same subject at a smaller, more appropriate size, then served in modern formats with responsive dimensions.
Accessibility benefits from that discipline as well. Decorative images can carry empty alt attributes so screen readers skip them, while informative images need concise descriptions that explain their purpose. Images placed in CSS backgrounds need an accessible equivalent when they convey meaning, and captions can provide context that an alt attribute lacks. Following WCAG principles also means checking text contrast, focus states and the order in which content is read, rather than adding compliance language to the page.
Type has a similar need for adaptable rules, which I set out in my responsive typography guide; image sizing should follow the same logic, with sensible breakpoints and text that remains readable without a picture. A fast page involves more than a small file size. It gives people a stable reading surface across devices, respects data limits and lets the content remain the reason they stayed.
A Visual Language That Can Grow
Over time, these choices can form a recognisable visual language. A recurring angle, a restrained palette and subjects encountered at street level may become more coherent than a collection sourced by keyword. The system can grow without becoming rigid. Some pages may carry one photograph, others only typography, and new work can be added when it contributes a genuine perspective rather than to keep a social feed visually active.
That approach also supports the Australian market for independent photographers, designers, ceramicists, booksellers and other small creative businesses. Commissioning local work can provide fair income and produce images suited to a specific audience. For a Melbourne maker, a portrait in a working studio may communicate more than a pristine stock scene of productivity. The transaction matters too: agreed fees, delivery formats and usage rights let both sides understand what the finished work is for.
Specificity also requires restraint around cultural material. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander artworks, designs, ceremonies and stories are not interchangeable decorative assets, and copyright permission alone may not satisfy community protocols. I would seek relevant cultural advice and use such material only where there is a genuine relationship and clear permission. The same care applies to places, events and people whose identity should not be flattened to make a page feel authentic.
The public-facing collection and current experiments live on my current home page. My working standard is simple: every image should add something I can stand behind, reveal a specific observation and remain consistent with the words. It may be a photograph I took, one made with care by someone I trust, or a deliberately plain graphic. Stock files have a place in commercial publishing, but on this site they dilute the authorship I am trying to make visible.